Re: Circ'ing a 4 month old - pros/cons?
What is his religious conviction?
If you're Jewish, a medical circumcision does not fulfill the covenant of one performed by a mohel. In other words, it doesn't "count". Humanistic and Reform Judaism do not require circumcision, nor do Christians. If it was for personal conviction as a Christian, then again, the medical circumcision would not be of benefit because medical circumcision is not the type of circumcision of the Old Testament and does not fulfill the Abrahamic covenant, plus we have the new covenant of Jesus through baptism that supersedes circumcision.
mama to Morgan 5/02, Elisha 5/05, Bethany 1/08 & Joshua 11/10
Last edited by annb; 11-17-2011 at 12:23 AM.