Re: Poll: which boy name do you like better?
I know this doesn't help a ton, but I like both names you listed. I love Jacob, even though it's kind of popular right now. William is just classic which is one reason I love it too. And I think it's great that you're naming him Scott after your DH's name, which is something we're doing as well. I think Jacob Scott sounds great too, if you decide to go with Jacob.
We were going to name our son William too, but since we wanted to call him Liam we are just going to name him Liam.