I've seen things go for up to 80% of retail in some markets! Depends on how seasoned your buying audience is, I think. Experienced CD FSOTers won't usually offer more than 50% except for newborn diapers, which usually go for upwards of 65%.
I've also sold hard-to-find items that I didn't even know I was sitting on for a lot of money. I bought a Sustainablebabyish interlock soaker at a garage sale for $10, used it for a year, and tried to give it away to someone who let me know that it was probably a hard to find color and year. I contacted an Sbish expert and got pricing help and ended up selling for $100. After I sold it, I got an offer for $150. I mean, what? It was so dingy-looking, too. That sale bought a good chunk of my newborn stash this time around.
Laura, mom to ds "Big D" (1.09), dd "Azalea" (10.10), and twin girls M and B (3.13)! Wife to my favorite. Cloth diaper industry geek. Birth geek. Church geek.
Last edited by March; 01-28-2013 at 10:16 AM.