Re: Is this punishment enough?
As far as the OP goes, I agree with stronger consequences for lying about it. The natural consequences of forgetting the planner would normally be missing out on the weekly "treat" but then to forge it calls for increased consequences. IMO you have found and implemented a reasonable and measured consequence for something he knew he did that was wrong.
You also made me LOL with your comment about his plea for pity about his sore hand, ha!! The drama!!
Jess, Happy wife & mom to 6 fun kids (ds11, ds9, dd7, ds5, ds3, and precious lil' ds born @ home 2/20/13)
I aim to encourage Christian women at Making Home