Re: Which was more painful overall...
I voted c-section. I have had a c-section after a failed induction with my first, a VBAC with my second and then another c-section with my third due to macrosomnia. Now, I am pregnant with my fourth, and driving two hours way to go for a VBA2C. :] Obviously, I really want to avoid the pain of a c-section again! Plus, I firmly believe that a VBAC is the safer option for both me and baby.
I am off to bed, but will come back to later to edit with more details.
A, wife to S (10/06), Mommy to W (6/08), B (9/09), my beautiful VBAC baby, L (6/11), and D (5/13), my VBA2C baby!