medela freestyle or pump in Style? Guess not medela swing?

[7arrows4God]

Okay I thought I would get the swing as I am ebf, and just want to collect when she misses a feeding when napping or first thing in morning, or maybe maybe in car when she nurses and I have let down. So thought I would stock up for when she does wean. Sometimes is earlier as pregnant again type thing. And right now would be nice to pump lots as I get lots of let downs. So time to stock up before that supply dwindles. But in reading reviews, it seems the tubing does not stay on, milk backs up and such and with a very busy household of many children that will drive me nuts, especially since it is still the decent amount of money even 2nd hand. Still hundred dollars. And I do not want only 2 ozs in 40 mins. No time for that.

So what would you choose pump in style or freestyle. What can get the most out shortly? Can you just pump one side while baby nursing on other side? Easiest to clean, use, and last? What are pros or cons to each one. Oh and I can get the pump in style used for the same hundred dollars as the swing.

Thanks Shannon mama to 11.

[crunchymom2b]

If you won'tbe pumping all that much the swing is just fine IMO. I have one and it works just fine when I need to pump out of the house. The only downside is it eats batteries. If you'll be pumping 1-2 times a day at least I'd go for the freestyle if you want portability while pumping, but if you can sit (but still pump hands free) while pumping the PISA is a great option too. I've heard more bad things about the freestyle than the PISA to be honest, but I'ddef. prefer a new freestyle over a used PISA.

[hohaas]

I have both the PISA and the Swing. The Swing is handy for on the go or around the house while doing things but it does go thru batteries quickly. I also don't think it pumps as effectively as the PISA. Both pumps are equal in cleaning and I have nursed and pumped at the same time w both.