Skip to Content

The Best Cloth Diaper Pails & Liners

Are you searching for the ideal solution for storing your cloth diapers in line with your preferred cleaning technique? With various options available, only some systems are compatible with the wet pail method or can contain odors for prolonged periods. A reliable storage system is essential if you prefer the wet pail method or if you intend to hold off washing the diapers for a few days.

Our team has conducted a thorough analysis of the top-rated cloth diaper pails and liners to assist you in avoiding the error of purchasing a system that isn’t suitable for your needs. We will provide an in-depth review of each product, highlighting their advantages and disadvantages.

Our Top Picks

Best Cloth Diaper Pails

Paytex Diaper Genie

While most people associate the Diaper Genie with disposable diapers, it can also be a great solution for cloth diapers. By using wet bag refills, you can easily integrate the Diaper Genie into your cloth diapering routine.

Trapping odors is a top priority for the Diaper Genie, and accomplishes this through multiple methods. With a built-in antimicrobial agent and double airtight clamps, it’s equipped to keep smells contained. Additionally, if any odor does manage to escape, a carbon filter serves as a final defense.

The Diaper Genie’s slim design is another advantage. It takes up minimal space and can fit snugly into most rooms, making it a great choice for parents who are tight on space.

Built in carbon fiber

Cannot hold water at the bottom for wet pail method

Munchkin Step Diaper Pail

This diaper pail is a fantastic choice for your nursery because of its subtle color, which won’t draw too much attention.

If you place a high value on odor control, this pail comes with a scented Arm & Hammer baking soda puck that will keep your nursery smelling fresh. Additionally, you can easily replace it with a different scented puck when it loses effectiveness.

The bag seals shut when the lid is closed to keep unpleasant smells at bay.
We adore the hands-free design, which allows you to step on the lever at the bottom of the pail to open the lid. This not only makes your life more convenient, but it also aids in reducing the spread of germs.

Self-sealing system traps odors by sealing the bag when you close the lid.
The company plants a tree for every pail sold
Works with rings and snap seal bags.

Slightly heavier at 12 pounds
You must purchase specific bags to go with the pail.

Safety 1st Easy Saver Diaper Pail

If you need to decide whether to use the wet or dry pail method, this diaper pail is a versatile option that accommodates both methods.

You don’t need to purchase specific plastic liners for this pail, as it can work with any kind.
At only two pounds, this lightweight unit can be easily moved around the nursery or home, no matter where you choose to place it.

Using this pail is effortless – simply raise the lid and drop the cloth diaper in. You won’t have to bend or twist while holding your wiggly baby.

Includes a deodorizer cover to help with the smell.

No child lock
Not hands-free opening

Busch Systems Odorless Gallon Diaper Pail

For parents looking for a diaper pail with cloth diapers, this option has a large opening that easily fits even the largest diaper without pushing or squeezing.

Although made of lightweight plastic, this pail is still sturdy and easy to move around the house.
If controlling odors is your top priority, this pail may put your mind at ease. It is designed with odor-free carbon filters and a lid that snaps shut on two sides to create a tight seal.

In addition, the carbon filter promotes airflow to combat mold while still containing odors.
This pail can accommodate both the dry and wet pail methods, making it a flexible choice if you still need to decide which method to use. You have the freedom to switch methods as you see fit.

Light weight

Little more spendy

Dekor Plus Hands Free Diaper Pail

This compact diaper pail is designed to seamlessly blend into your nursery decor, and it comes in various modern colors.

As a parent, you know how important it is to have hands-free options. That’s why we love the foot pedal opening feature on this pail. You can easily open it up without using your hands!
This product also has triple odor control to keep your nursery smelling fresh. The rubber seals and odor-resistant plastic work together to keep the smells contained.

When it comes to safety, this pail goes above and beyond. It has multiple child locks to ensure that your little one stays safe. The opening lid, access door, and cover all have locks to prevent accidents.

If you’re looking for a diaper pail with enhanced safety measures, this is a great option.

Can be used for cloth diapers or disposable.
Reusable refill cartridges.
Comes completely assembled.

Can’t be used for the wet pail method.

What Is A Cloth Diaper Pail?

A standard diaper pail is intended for disposing of disposable diapers. However, if you’re using cloth diapers, you’ll need a different type of pail.

Unlike disposable diapers, cloth diapers need to be stored somewhere until laundry day. It’s essential to have a suitable place to store them so that the smell doesn’t linger or mold doesn’t develop.

A designated cloth diaper pail is ideal for discreetly storing soiled cloth diapers until it’s time to clean them. Keeping them in a laundry basket or a trash bag is not advisable.

Different Types Of Diaper Pails

There are various options available for cloth diaper pails and liners, but ultimately, whether to use a wet pail or dry pail system depends on personal preference.

Dry Pail Method

The dry pail method is the most commonly used approach. Line your diaper pail with a waterproof liner and place your dry diapers inside. Removing any solid waste before putting the diapers in the pail is important to avoid clogging your washing machine.

Wet Pail Method

The wet pail method involves pre-soaking the diapers in water before placing them in the pail. This helps to minimize stains and odors. However, it’s important to note that the presence of water poses a potential drowning hazard for young children. To avoid this, you can purchase a diaper pail with a lock or stick to the dry pail method.

Diaper Pail Liners

Some diaper pails do not require liners, while others do. However, liners offer several advantages that make them a valuable addition to many pails.

Do Diaper Pails Need Liners?

Using a liner in your diaper pail may not be mandatory, but it can offer significant advantages.

Reduced cleaning: A cloth diaper pail liner adds an extra layer of protection to the pail’s interior, preventing bacterial buildup and reducing the frequency of pail cleaning.

Convenient washing: Carrying a pail filled with dirty diapers to the laundry room can be challenging and unhygienic. A liner makes removing and transporting the diapers to the washer easier.

Odor control: Liners come in various types, including scented ones and others that allow you to use deodorizers effectively, which can help combat unpleasant smells.
Some diaper pails may need specific liners, so keep that in mind when choosing one to purchase.

The Best Pail Liners

Teamoy Reusable Pail Liner

Not all liners are designed to be used with a diaper pail, but if you are concerned about leaks, it is advisable to use one.Teamoy offers high-quality liners that are perfect for parents who want to avoid the pail method and rely solely on liners.These liners are sturdy, waterproof and can be attached to various household items.

You can clip the bag to a towel bar, hook, rack, or even a changing table using the snaps.
The product includes two machine washable liners, so you can easily switch to the next one when it’s time to wash, always keeping one in reserve.

Additionally, numerous trendy colors and styles are available to complement your decor if you decide not to use a diaper pail.

Snug elastic to fit most diaper pails.
Durable to lock in odors.
Handles include snaps so you can hang the bags anywhere.

Can’t hold as many diapers if used without a pail.

Alvababy Reusable Diaper Pail Liner

To ensure a proper fit, it’s essential to choose a diaper pail liner that’s suitable for the method you’re using.

This liner is constructed with waterproof material to prevent any leakage. Avoiding any unwanted and unpleasant fluids leaking from the liner is important.

With a capacity of 20-25 diapers, it is sufficient for a newborn baby for up to two days.
This liner conveniently attaches to most diaper pails, reducing the risk of accidental slippage.
You can easily move your diapers from the pail to the laundry without touching them.

Machine-washable is one of the most significant benefits of this liner.
Despite being concealed inside the diaper pail, you can select a color that complements your style or nursery decor.

Thick fabric ensures it won’t leak.

The liner color is sometimes a different shade than pictured.

Biloban Diaper Pail Liner

The Biloban diaper liners offer excellent value for money by providing two liners for the price of one.

A spare liner is always helpful, so you have a backup when it’s time to clean one.
These liners are machine-friendly, so you can easily clean them whenever needed.
The reliable stitching ensures that leaks won’t occur, while the waterproof material protects against potential leaks.

Thanks to the elastic tops, these liners can fit on any diaper pail with a size up to 13 gallons.
Once your diaper days are over, you can repurpose these liners. They’re spacious enough to be used in trash cans as an alternative to trash bags!

Thick material and strong elastic.
100% money-back guarantee.

The elastic top can make it difficult to fully air dry.

The Best Diaper Pail Deodorizers

Ninja Mama Bamboo Carbon Charcoal Diaper Pail Filter

These bamboo carbon filters are designed to tackle odors without drawing attention to themselves.

The filters have a lifespan of about two weeks but can be recharged in sunlight for an additional 15 days. With a pack of 12, you can use one for an entire year.

While some diaper pails have a designated spot for the filter, others may not. Regardless, you can easily attach the filter to the lid with tape or place it at the bottom of the pail, as long as you’re not using the wet pail method.

Year-long odor protection

May need to use two at once for stronger smells

Purifyou All Natural Diaper Pail Deodorizer

Even the strongest diaper pail or liner can’t completely eliminate odors. To keep your nursery smelling fresh, it’s best to have multiple methods in place, and that’s where these deodorizers come in.

These deodorizers are made of large, eco-friendly, highly porous granules that are excellent at eliminating odors.

You can easily attach them to the underside of your diaper pail lid or place them at the bottom if you use a liner.

Helps filters and purify air
Hypoallergenic product.

Only Last for 2 to 3 months

Cloth Diaper Pail & Liner FAQ

How often should I change my cloth diaper pail liner?

This will depend on how often you’re using the diaper pail, but generally it’s a good idea to change the liner every 2-3 days.

How do I clean my cloth diaper pail liner?

Most diaper pail liners can be machine washed, but be sure to check the care instructions before washing. Here is everything you need to know about how to clean a diaper pail.

Can I use a regular trash bag as a liner for my cloth diaper pail?

While it’s possible to use a regular trash bag as a liner, it’s generally not recommended as they may not be strong enough to contain the weight and smell of soiled diapers.

How often should I replace my cloth diaper pail filter?

This will depend on the type of filter you’re using, but most filters should be replaced every 3-6 months.

With various options available on the market, it’s important to consider factors such as durability, size, ease of use, and odor control when selecting the best option for your needs. Using a cloth diaper pail and liner can save time and hassle while keeping your nursery clean and fresh.